Inexpensive Replacement Materials Don’t Stack Up to Originals

Inexpensive and maintenance free or short sighted and maintenance proof: How do substitute materials stack up in the long run? By John H. Cluver, AIA

The pressure to replace historic materials with inexpensive substitutes is strong. There are arguments, however, to support keeping those original clapboards and roofs. 

Marketers would have you believe that there are fundamental problems with historic materials that require their replacement. Rotten wood, peeling paint, cracks and loss of function, however, can be repaired and, more importantly, can be prevented. The real problems are aggressive marketing, a lack of knowledge about historic materials and a focus on short term costs to the detriment of the long term. The unfortunate results are the five fables of modern replacement materials that contribute to the lowcost, low-maintenance mirage.

Fable #1: Replacement is cheaper than repair; substitutes are relatively cheap and traditional materials simply cannot compete on price.What people fail to consider, however, is that repairing what already exists may cost the same, or possibly even be cheaper. So why don’t more people do repairs, if price is so important? In most cases, it is because they do not even think that repair is an option, either because they do not know where to find someone to do the job or because they assume it will cost more.

Fable #2: The best price is the best deal. When it comes to construction, it is very hard to comparison shop. Because people buy items like roofs only once or twice in their lifetime, and rarely own the product from start to finish, they are not educated consumers. Lacking proper knowledge and not wanting to get “sold up,” the natural tendency is to simply buy the most affordable option out there. Marketing has successfully removed the question of quality from most buyers’ minds by offering a “lifetime warranty” that frequently either the buyer or the seller are not around to cash-in on.

Fable #3: New looks better than old. Unless you are an old house aficionado, there is a great satisfaction in removing those old, peeling, ratty-looking materials and replacing them with something new.The problem is, today’s new is tomorrow’s old, and many contemporary materials simply do not age as gracefully as traditional materials.

Fable #4: Replacement is more energy efficient than repair.With increased environmental awareness and rising energy costs, people get great satisfaction in upgrading the energy efficiency of their house by replacing materials that are drafty and allow heat to escape. Unfortunately, they fail to take the steps, like increasing insulation or sealing cracks, which can have a bigger impact on heat loss. It may take decades for the replacement material to “pay for itself ” in energy savings, but heat loss is only part of the equation: It takes energy to make, ship and install new materials, as well as to remove and dispose of the old materials.

Fable #5: No maintenance is the ultimate goal. Everybody wants more time and mundane house maintenance is never high on anybody’s priority list. So why spend time and money repairing a material that will need constant maintenance, when that money can be spent on something that can be installed and never thought of again? Very often, periodic maintenance can prevent more expensive and disruptive major repairs later. Even paying someone to paint the house while you relax on the hammock will cost less than new siding. 

Ready to Get Started?

Click below to share a few details and request a call back.

Always Helpful

Brian came out last week to try to assess a problem we are having in our yard.  He arrived on time, was extremely courteous and took a considerable amount of time analyzing our situation.  While he was unable to reach a solution, he did take the time to research and recommend another business that might be able to help us.  That kind of customer service will make us more likely to call on Hertzler & George if other issues arise.  Thanks, Brian!


Five Stars All Around

We hired H&G to help us re-do our landscaping after a different local landscaping company did a sub par job with plant selections and installations. That company also was very hard to deal with. H&G stepped right up with Jennifer creating a new planting scheme comprising of native plants with some we had never seen before and which we love! She is extremely knowledgeable and pleasant to work with – a true landscaping charm! Jon did the installations and also did a fantastic job. He was very meticulous on planting and finishing the job neatly with mulch. Unlike that other company’s installer, Jon left us extremely happy with the job done. Customer service on the phone – pleasant, patient and helpful. The only, and ever so minor aspect of their work, is they don’t offer a guarantee on the plants or install. I suppose that’s becoming industry standard. However, now looking over all the plantings with a bit of time passing, I am confident that there won’t need to be any replacements. Watering is of course the key element. Thank you H&G, the country cottage landscaping we’ve wanted is now ours – FIVE STARS!

Chris Dombrowski
Ford's Colony | Homeowner

True professionals

Had these guys build a surface-grade patio in May 2023. They looked at the project, sent me a proposed scope of work and contract via email, took a deposit of 1/2 the total via bank transfer. They set a date weeks later to start the job. They showed up on time, worked professionally and cleaned up at the end of the day. Whole job took 3 days, and they even replaced all the patio furniture on the last day. The final product was precisely what I asked for, done in a high-quality, workmanlike way.

H&G are not the cheapest guys out there, but for the extra money you get a professional product, professionally executed, on time, on budget. Honestly: I don’t think it gets any better than that.


Ken Blakely

Beyond Satisfied

We had an ugly uneven weedy patio and a driveway that needed reshaping and gravel. The transformation is stunning. Your representative Brian was patient and helpful in designing repairs to our satisfaction and your work crew was exceptional. Edwardo the work site foreman was extremely knowledgeable and professional and created a beautiful patio. His crew was superior.

Tim & Cynthia Porter

Joe Hertzler goes the extra mile

Hertzler and George were contracted to perform some landscaping for a seller of mine to get the home ready to show. They had just finished an extensive re-landscaping of the next door neighbors entire yard. I was very impressed by their attention to detail and their desire to satisfy their client. Joe Hertzler goes the extra mile to achieve complete client satisfaction. They provide a complete mix of landscaping design services and maintenance of existing landscaping

Tim Parker
Liz Moore Real Estate